Simple bending of a reinforced concrete section to the French BAEL 91 code (revised 1999), in particular for existing structures designed to former codes, and comparison with Eurocode 2 for a rectangular section.

The sheet applies French codes: its interface and the PDF calculation note are in French.

How to use

  • Choose the case studied (“Cas étudié”): BAEL calculation (rectangular, T or any polygonal section, several reinforcement layers) or comparison with EC2 (rectangular section, same moments, reinforcement specific to each code).
  • Enter the section, materials (fc28, fe, type of steel), reinforcement and the moments Mu and Mser, then the cracking class.
  • The advanced options give access to the γb, θ and γs factors and to the concrete stress block at ULS.
  • “Calculer” gives the verdict, the utilisation ratio of each criterion and suggestions; the PDF calculation note can be downloaded below the results.

Assumptions

  • Ultimate limit state (A.4.3): parabola-rectangle or simplified rectangular stress block, fbu = 0.85·fc28/(θ·γb), elastic-perfectly plastic steel fsu = fe/γs; design from the reduced moment and resisting moment from section equilibrium.
  • Serviceability (A.4.5): cracked transformed section (n = 15 by default); concrete compression limited to 0.6·fc28 (A.4.5,2), steel stress according to the cracking class (A.4.5,3).
  • Minimum reinforcement (non-brittleness condition) and maximum reinforcement ratio of 5%.
  • Comparison: simplified design in both codes, with fck = fc28 for Eurocode 2.

Example

Slab, 25 cm thick, of an old structure, per 1 m strip: fc28 = 25 MPa, Fe E 400 steel, 10 HA16 bars, Mu = 110 kN·m, Mser = 75 kN·m.

✔ Section verified

Maximum utilisation ratio: 0.91 — governing criterion: resisting moment (ULS)

MRd
121.4 kN·m
As required
1,786 mm²
σbc
10.50 MPa
σs
217.9 MPa

Comparison with Eurocode 2 (21 cm slab): the same section passes to EC2 (ratio 0.95) but not to BAEL (1.17), mainly because of the steel, 434.8 MPa for B500B against 347.8 MPa for Fe E 400 (load the comparison).

Load this example into the sheet Calculation note of the example (PDF, 3 pages, in French)

SLS neutral axis1000 mm250 mm
Example section, to scale: 10 HA16 bars per metre; dashed, the SLS neutral axis (y1 = 83.5 mm).
Formulas, limits and references

fbu = 0.85·fc28/(θ·γb); fsu = fe/γs
μ = Mu/(b·d²·fbu); boundary between pivots A and B: μ = 0.186

Limits

  • Simple bending of a rectangular, T or arbitrary section, up to eight layers; no axial force, shear or prestressed concrete.
  • For existing structures and comparisons; a new design falls under Eurocode 2.
  • Comparison on a rectangular section; not covered: deflections, fatigue, detailing.

References: BAEL 91 rules revised 99 (A.2, A.4.2, A.4.3, A.4.5), full text in our useful documents; EN 1992-1-1 and its French National Annex for the comparison.

Check: both examples checked by hand (μ, α, z, As, σs).

Frequently asked questions

Why still calculate to BAEL?

Most structures in service were designed to BAEL or earlier codes. For a diagnosis or a strengthening, the first step is what the structure offered under its original rules.

Does an unfavourable Eurocode result condemn the structure?

No. Reassessing an existing structure relies on the original code, the actual properties of the materials (tests) and the loads actually applied.

Which concrete stress block should I use at ULS?

The parabola-rectangle (A.4.3,41) is the reference diagram; the simplified rectangular block (A.4.3,42) gives very close results. Both are in the advanced options.

See also

Sheet for preliminary design and routine checks, provided for guidance only: it does not replace a calculation note prepared by an engineer. Found an issue or have a suggestion? Write to us.